Conference Championship Picks

I only trust one of these QBs on Sunday, and it's not the one with the better playoff record.

The bad news is that an 0-4 performance last week guarantees me a losing record in this year's playoffs (a far step down from my 10-1 mark from last year). The good news is that my preseason Super Bowl pick of Patriots vs. Falcons is still alive. I'm feeling much more confident about one of those teams than the other.

Last Week: 0-4
Playoffs: 3-5
Regular Season: 132-119-5

San Francisco 49ers at Atlanta Falcons

As a BC alumnus and someone who dislikes judging a player's career on the outcome of three games, I was happy to see Matt Ryan throw the monkey off his back in his final drive against the Seahawks. But I was troubled that his defense put him in that position to begin with. In the second half, Atlanta's D struggled to contain Russell Wilson's mobility, just as they struggled in two meetings with Cam Newton in the regular season. If Colin Kaepernick is even half as good as he was against the Packers, the 49ers will still move the ball on Sunday. And after I just spent a couple of days breaking down Michael Crabtree's development into one of the most complete wide receivers in the league (you can read my PFF article here), I'm convinced that he'll have a much bigger impact than the one reception and three yards that he gained in last year's NFC Championship.

Divisional Round Playoff Picks

A less-than-healthy Justin Smith may not be enough to stop Aaron Rodgers.

Just like last year, a ho-hum Wild Card Weekend was salvaged by some drama in the late Sunday game. I'm in the party that thought it was irresponsible of Mike Shanahan to leave his limping quarterback on the field. I understand that Robert Griffin is a warrior and I have no doubt that he lobbied to stay in. But a coach's job is to look past the opinions of his players and do what's in the best interests, both short-term and long-term, of the team. I don't understand how some people gave Shanahan a pass for botching a decision that every baseball manager has to make when his starting pitcher pleas for one more inning. And if Shanahan decided that leaving Griffin in was indeed the best thing for the Redskins, then he should have owned up to that. Instead, he hid behind some "he told me it was okay and I believed him" defense, shifting responsibility from himself to his player. Shanahan is often referred to as a Hall of Fame coach, despite the fact that he's won one playoff game in the 14 years since John Elway retired. If his bad decision ends up hurting his franchise quarterback's career, he may be waiting a long time for the second.

Last Week: 3-1
Regular Season: 132-119-5

Baltimore Ravens at Denver Broncos

Disclaimer: Back in Week 1,  I chose the Patriots over the Broncos and Falcons over the Packers in the Championship games, so my picks are a bit biased towards that outcome. The pick I'm most confident in is this one. The Broncos haven't lost since starting 2-3, and even their defeats came against teams that are still in the playoff race. Towards the end of the season it seemed like Peyton Manning was merely tinkering with his offense every Sunday, trying new plays and different combinations while blowing out the Raiders on the side.  The Ravens couldn't stop Knowshon Moreno or Von Miller in Week 15, and they'll now be relying on two players, Ray Lewis and Michael Oher, whose reputations far outweigh their performance. Manning has had some of the most puzzling playoff defeats of the last decade, but I don't see that happening here.

The Pick: Broncos (-9.5)

End of Season Awards and Wild Card Weekend Picks

How important is an elite running back in a quarterback-dominated league?

I can honestly saw that I've never had an NFL season pass by as quickly as this one did. I feel like we've only had a few weeks of football, and yet somehow the playoffs are here. Without further ado, here are my regular season awards.

Offensive Rookie of the Year: Russell Wilson, QB, Seattle Seahawks
The frontrunner for this award changed on a weekly basis throughout the season, and in the end it was a dark horse who eked past the favorites at the wire. Andrew Luck would win this race in most other years, but his high interception mark and poor accuracy drops him from contention. It's tough to separate Wilson and Robert Griffin III with statistics alone. Wilson has thrown six more touchdowns, Griffin has thrown five fewer interceptions. Griffin ranks third in our PFF QB Rating and second in our Accuracy Percentage, Wilson ranks fourth in both categories. Griffin had nearly twice as many rushing yards, but Wilson stretched the field with nearly twice as many deep-passing yards. I couldn't fault anyone for going with Griffin, but I'm choosing Wilson because he led his team to a better record against tougher competition, going 11-5 overall and 5-1 against teams that finished with a winning record while Griffin went 9-6 and 3-3, respectively. Perhaps we can just give the award to the winner of this week's playoff game?

Defensive Rookie of the Year: Casey Hayward, CB, Green Bay Packers
Some will see Luke Kuechly's league-leading 164 tackles and hand him this award, but that would be mistaking activity for productivity. Kuechly had a dreadful September and his eagerness to make a play often got him in trouble in coverage, where he surrendered the seventh-most receiving yards of any inside linebacker. Without the first-round hype, Hayward terrorized opposing quarterbacks by allowing zero touchdowns and snagging six interceptions. QBs had a 31.1 passer rating when throwing at him, the lowest mark for any starting cornerback in the league.

Comeback Player of the Year: Peyton Manning, QB, Denver Broncos
My least favorite award because the criteria is so vague and up to interpretation. I still can't believe the season Adrian Peterson had after tearing his ACL just over one year ago. Nevertheless, I think we all knew that AP would eventually return to his elite production eventually. On the other hand, as Manning missed an entire season with a neck injury, there was a point where we thought that he'd never play another snap in the NFL. Instead, he's returned to his usual spot as one of the best players the game has ever seen.